 |
Because of
the laws
of refraction, fish cannot see any part of an object which lies below
an angle of 10 degrees to the water surface at the edge
of their "window".
The red
triangles in this diagram show this "blind spot" extending outwards all
around the edge of the trout's window.
[ Diagram adapted from Fig. 6 in Professor L T Threadgold's
book
"Dry Flies: An Improved Method of Tying" see Ref#2
]
The
next set of pictures apply this law of refraction to show the effect of
standing upright and crouching on an angler's visibility to trout . |
 |
The head and
upper body of the standing angler would be
visible to a trout lying
beside the clump of midstream vegetation on the right hand side of the
photograph.
(The triangles in these picture were created using GIMP see Ref#3. The
calculations were made using an online calculator see Ref#1.) |
 |
But if the
angler crouches, only his head would
be
visible to a trout lying
beside the clump of midstream vegetation on the right hand
side of the photograph. |
| We can
begin to answer
our question: What is a safe distance? |
| Angler is: |
Height of angler (in feet) |
Distance angler invisible to trout (in feet).
Based on calculation made with aid of Ref#1
|
| Standing |
6 feet |
=>34 feet |
| Crouching |
4 feet |
=>23 feet |
Things to bear in mind:
This doesn't mean you need to have 23 or 34 feet of fly line
outside your rod tip, because:
- the leader is probably 9 feet or longer
- your rod is probably 7 feet or longer
Assuming your leader straightens out, and you hold the rod straight out
in front of you with the tip at water level:
- if you are standing, you might get away with
casting just 18 feet
(34-(9+7)) of fly line
- if you are crouching, you might get
away with casting just 7 feet
(23-(9+7)) of fly line
But of course these assumptions are very unlikely (for example, your
may want your leader to contain slack to avoid drag etc.) so you should
cast a
few extra feet of fly line to be safe.
In addition, the depth
at which the trout is lying also has an important effect.
So far I have
assumed that you are casting to a trout lying close to the surface: A
trout lying 6 inches below the surface has a small 5 inch
window
(Shown on the far right of the diagram below).
But if the trout is 6 feet beneath the surface (far left in the diagram
below) its window has a radius over 5 feet. So the radius needs to be added
to the "rule of thumb" introduced at the top of this page,
because the
law of refraction operates from the edge of the trout's "window".
Or to put it another way, a deep-lying trout is closer to you (in
optical terms) than you think.
|
|
|

Image from Ref#4 |
|
References:
- Right Triangle Angle And Side Calculator
- Professor L T Threadgold. "Dry Flies: An Improved
Method of Tying", Swan Hill Press, Shrewsbury, 1998
- GIMP the GNU Image Manipulation
Program
- How Does a Trout Catch a Fly?: Marinaro's
"Edge of the Window Theory"
|